S3 E11, Turning ideas that matter into a business that delivers, James Rutter, Chief Strategy Officer, Cook

Sep 14, 2026

James Rutter of Cook on why customers buy an amazing product, not a purpose, and how strategy, culture and brand fit together in a force-for-good business.

Listen on Spotify

Listen on Apple Podcasts

Watch on YouTube

James Rutter, Chief Strategy officer, Cook

70-second trailer

James Rutter has spent much of his career exploring how ideas can create meaningful change. Now Chief Strategy Officer at Cook, James began his career in business and finance journalism. While he enjoyed uncovering and shaping ideas, he increasingly questioned whether they truly mattered. A personal purpose exercise later helped him define his guiding principle: ‘to find, shape and share ideas that matter’.

The belief at Cook that business can and should be a force for good, has shaped both James’s career and the company’s growth. Over more than 15 years, he has helped guide the business’s strategy, culture and brand, and now seeks to share those lessons with other purpose-driven organisations.

Today, Cook employs around 2,000 people, generates approximately £150m in annual sales, operates four production kitchens and runs around 120 shops nationwide. James believes its success comes from aligning strategy, culture and brand: strategy provides clarity of direction, culture creates the energy to deliver it, and brand becomes the external expression of that culture.

Influenced by Simon Sinek’s work on purpose, Peter Drucker’s thinking on culture, and strategist Alex Smith’s distinction between ‘company story’ and ‘customer story’, James argues that memorable brands are built from authentic culture rather than marketing alone.

While Cook has long championed purpose and played a role in the growth of the B Corp movement in the UK, James is clear that customers ultimately buy great products, not missions. Purpose matters most when it strengthens the organisation behind an outstanding product or service.

Two themes run through James’s story: the importance of clarity in connecting impact and commercial goals, and the belief that long-term purpose requires the courage to stay focused through inevitable short-term setbacks.

Visit Cook at: cookfood.net

Connect with James at: james-rutter.com/contact or linkedin.com/in/james-rutter-8972079

Running a business with purpose at its heart?

Ned Wells headshot uploaded March 2026
I’m Ned Wells, host of The Impact Files. I'm also a fractional marketing director for purpose-led businesses, giving you the marketing leadership you need to deliver the business plan, without the cost of a full-time hire.

Transcript

The Impact Files Podcast – James Rutter, Chief Strategy Officer, Cook

Ned Wells: Welcome to The Impact Files podcast. This week, Ally and I are joined by James Rutter, Chief Strategy Officer at Cook – most of the time. James, welcome to the podcast.

James Rutter: Thank you, Ned. Hello, Ally.

Ally Dunnett: Hi, welcome, James.

James Rutter: Thank you. Yeah, most of the time – well, three days a week, actually. I’m Chief Strategy Officer at Cook these days, and on the other two I do my own thing. It’s a fairly recent evolution, but it’s fun.

Ned Wells: Okay. And what sort of things do you call your own thing?

James Rutter: Good question. I’d say I cover strategy, culture and brand, probably in that order. I have my strategy role at Cook, but I also do culture work at Cook as well. Historically, I used to do brand and marketing – I was Chief Creative Officer at Cook for many years. So I’ve let go of that part of my role there, so that I’ve got a bit more time to really go out into the world and hopefully help some other businesses around strategy, culture and brand, and how those three fit together.

Ned Wells: Right.

James Rutter: And, again, definitely with a desire to work with people who are trying to make a positive impact and use business as a force for good.

Ned Wells: I really want to dig down into that a lot more in a minute or two. But perhaps we could start with an introduction to you and your personal story. I remember you saying, when we spoke off air, that you started as a financial journalist. Is that right?

James Rutter: Yes, that is right. I had a first career in business and finance journalism, as a writer and editor. And I was thinking about this – I think it is ultimately about personal purpose. Have you guys done a personal purpose exercise? Do you have your personal purpose statements? I’d love to know.

Ally Dunnett: I do not. I was thinking I’m sure I could conjure it up off the top of my head, but in fact I’m not sure I could. I should do it more thoughtfully. It’s a very interesting idea. How about you, Ned?

Ned Wells: I don’t think I’ve done a discrete, fixed-scope exercise, but I’ve thought very carefully, long and hard, about it. And actually, I think this podcast is a lot about that. Capitalism is the world we live in, and we need money for all sorts of reasons. I’m interested in how organisations make the short-term revenue they need, but with one eye on long-term purpose, environmentally and socially. That’s what I’m most interested in, and that’s what I want to support and drive, partly through this podcast.

James Rutter: Yeah. Simon Sinek, for all his faults, is good at what he does, and he’s got a brilliant “find your personal why” type of book-come-format. I went through it with a friend about 10 years ago, and it’s really good. It delves into the story of your life and your career – what’s lit you up, what have been your low points – and from that, you define your own driving purpose. Mine is to find, shape and share ideas that matter. And even 10 years on, I still think that’s a really good summary of what lights me up.

For the first 10 years of my career, coming out of university and going into business and finance journalism, I was certainly finding and shaping ideas, and I loved that. I loved going out to talk to people – CEOs in banking and finance and that kind of thing. Fascinating people. But I wasn’t really sure that those ideas mattered in the big sense. They made lots of people lots of money, but they didn’t necessarily matter.

So when I left that world and joined Cook, which was completely out of the blue, I went into – probably without fully realising it at the time – a company with an idea that really mattered: that business can and should be a force for good. And particularly in the UK at that time, helping launch and grow the B Corp movement was a real way that we could have a bigger impact beyond just our own business.

So that driving purpose has definitely shaped my career. And in a way, the move I’ve made in the last year, to have a couple of days doing something as well as Cook, is again with that bigger purpose in mind. I saw the opportunity to take all our learnings from 15-plus years of successfully growing a very purpose-driven and impactful business, take those learnings out into the world, and help other people who are on that journey, maybe at a slightly earlier or very early stage – to pass on some of that wisdom, hopefully, to help other people use business as a force for good.

Ally Dunnett: So that really speaks to the “share” part of your personal purpose, right? You’ve implemented it, and you’re continuing to drive it forward in the organisation you work for, and now you’ve had this opportunity to share beyond that.

James Rutter: Absolutely. Why bother saying yes to a podcast like this? Because, fundamentally, it’s all about sharing ideas that matter.

Ned Wells: And is there a particular style of business that you ideally want to be supporting and working with for those two days a week?

James Rutter: All comers welcome. I’m a broad church of one. It’s been really interesting. As you may have perspective on, working inside a business for a long time is wonderful in many respects. But stepping away from that, at least some of the time, and suddenly having a broader perspective – seeing how different people operate and do things, and what other issues are driving people’s behaviour – is just fascinating and enriching in equal measure.

Ned Wells: Mm.

James Rutter: I definitely want to work with businesses where I can see there is a desire to be a force for good in some way, shape or form. I’m not being didactic about that, in the sense that it has to be a B Corp, or it has to be this or that. But I’m drawn towards businesses that have a bigger sense of purpose than just maximising the money they can make. And equally, businesses that have a sense of being able to create something valuable through people.

One of the joys we have as business people is bringing people together to achieve something bigger than they could ever achieve alone. So let’s make sure we’re giving them the opportunity to really find fulfilment and purpose through what they’re doing, and that what we’re asking them to do is worthwhile in the bigger scheme. I think one of the most obvious but overlooked aspects of purposeful, impactful business is to create great workplaces that people feel energised and inspired to be part of. Because that’s definitely going to ripple out in all kinds of positive ways.

Ally Dunnett: I’d be interested to know, James, whether any organisations have approached you in your personal work where purpose perhaps hasn’t been near the top of their agenda. As you say, you’re not being overly choosy. But perhaps they’ve started off with it not high on their agenda, and then, either by osmosis or in a more conscious way, they’ve taken stock, listened to what you had to say, and really bumped purpose up the agenda. Has that happened?

James Rutter: Funnily enough, I was talking just this morning to an entrepreneur who’s grown a good business over five or six years, but has got to a point where he’s feeling a certain emptiness in terms of why he’s still doing it. So he wants to explore that and articulate it. He’s got a sense that there is some kind of inner drive there that isn’t just about making money, but he’s not quite sure how to pull that out of himself and articulate it in a way that’s going to inspire him. And, as he said to me, “I’ve now got a team coming to me saying, ‘Look, we want to know why we’re doing this. Yes, we enjoy turning up for work, but over five years, what’s going to be the point?'”

So whether you call it purpose or something else, having that sense of direction, and a clear sense of what you’re seeking to achieve in the bigger picture – not just the business metrics – is so important for galvanising your team, creating energy within a business, and carrying that momentum through into your business success.

Historically, people have often looked at that kind of cultural work as a nice-to-have – a bit fluffy. And yet it’s arguably the most tangible business driver there is: people who are inspired and engaged in their work, really turning up wanting to do a brilliant job – not because of the bonus being dangled at the end of it, but because they feel what they’re doing is worthwhile, they’re in great relationships with people, and they feel they can grow personally and professionally.

Ally Dunnett: Yeah. And following on from that, people have perhaps struggled with the cultural side, thinking, “Because it’s intangible, we can’t measure it. And because we can’t measure it, we’ll shove it to one side and focus on the financial KPIs, or whatever they may be.” It would be interesting to hear about the tools or frameworks you do use to measure happiness at work and those other cultural elements.

James Rutter: I think there is a danger in seeking to measure everything. That isn’t to say you shouldn’t seek some measures. But there’s always an inherent risk in saying, “Unless we can measure it, we can’t tell whether it’s been valuable to us or not.” That’s one of the curses of the modern age, isn’t it? We seek to make every single area of our lives measurable, turning it into ever more minute data points, and somehow think that pursuing each one of those will add up to something incredibly productive and rewarding. Whereas perhaps part of the secret is to let go of that desire to measure everything, step back, take a much more holistic view of what’s going on, and just feel instinctively that we’re going in the right direction. I know that’s anathema to most modern business folk, but I think there’s some definite truth in it.

That said, you can still have some measures for culture, even though I don’t think they’re exact. Going back to 2012, I want to say, we started doing the Best Companies to Work For survey, which at the time, in the Sunday Times, was the top one. We did it because we wanted a measure. We didn’t pretend it was going to be perfect, but it gave us a sense of whether we were progressing. We’ve done it every year since, and I want to say we might be the only company that’s been in the top 100 every year since 2013. The first year we did it, we came about 300th and were devastated. Then we came something like 82nd and celebrated like we’d won the World Cup.

Ally Dunnett: Yeah.

James Rutter: Since then, we’ve done it every year as a benchmark for where we’re at. It doesn’t describe our success or failure in terms of culture in any fullness, but it gives us a regular benchmark that says, “Okay, this is where we’re at as an organisation.” So having some kind of measure is definitely great. But don’t pretend that chasing the measurements is going to result in the outcome you want.

Ally Dunnett: Makes complete sense.

Ned Wells: Just in terms of metrics, and for any listeners who may not be familiar with Cook, how large is the organisation? What sort of scale are we talking about?

James Rutter: These days Cook is about 2,000 people, and we’re about £150 million in terms of sales. And we’re a very unusual business, I always think. I’d say we’ve got the whole of humanity under our umbrella, because we’re vertically integrated. We’re a manufacturer – we make nearly all of our own food, in four big kitchens. We also own shops, so we have a retail estate of about 120 shops nationwide these days. And then we have all the central functions – marketing, finance, what have you – and logistics as well, trucking things around.

So we have an incredibly diverse workforce, and that is one of the joys of being at Cook: we can create a culture in which everybody feels welcome across that very broad spectrum of people, and everybody feels some unity around our values – our “essential ingredients”, as we call them. And everybody feels a sense of purpose in the business, which I think is very different from their personal purpose, but we can talk about that if you like. If we can create that kind of culture, that’s a wonderful thing. And it definitely keeps everybody connected to society in the broad sense, in a way that businesses with teams focused on a particular demographic often lose – that broader cultural perspective.

Ned Wells: I’m curious – and I think we’ll dig into this as we go on – about how your experience of working for an organisation of that scale translates to the rough and tumble of a smaller organisation. In some senses, there are aspects of large organisations that don’t particularly translate, and I suspect the cultural side would be more translatable, if you see what I mean.

James Rutter: Yeah, I would say most of it translates, to be honest, because ultimately the basic frameworks by which you want to operate are the same, whether you’re £1 million, £100 million or £1 billion. You could argue that the bigger you get, the more complicated it all gets, and the more susceptible you are to drift, in some respects. And remember, Cook wasn’t always that big. Back when I started, we had a £25-30 million turnover and a team of 500. Still sizeable by some standards, but definitely not the size we are today.

Ned Wells: Yeah.

James Rutter: But, like I say, particularly around the areas I’m interested in, I think it all applies: strategy, and getting real clarity around that; culture, and how you build energy through your people; and the brand, and how your comms and your brand bring vitality to the whole endeavour. Those apply whether you’re a one-man band – which, remember, I now am two days a week – or a 2,000-person, £150 million business.

Ned Wells: Yes. So let’s dig back down into what you said about strategy. Strategy classically takes a long-term outlook. How should leaders tackle the balance between achieving the near-term economic results they need and their longer-term sustainability objectives?

James Rutter: That balance of long and short term is a challenge for everyone. And there are differences between short-term needs. Some might be a survival situation: “We just need to make X to keep going.” Others are short-term financial needs that are more like, “We need to make X to keep the bank or the investors happy,” or, “We need to make X because we want to keep ourselves happy, or because we said we would,” or whatever it is. So I think you have to qualify that short-term financial pressure.

And then you have to keep in mind that the long term is made up of lots of short terms added together. It’s like that classic – I think it’s a Keynes quote – something along the lines of “the long term is made up of the short term multiplied many times.” So the two are connected. And the trick, or the secret, in any credible and successful strategy is to acknowledge and embrace that fact, and use it to arrive at your long-term destination.

The particular challenge comes when you’re layering on outcomes of different kinds – so a financial outcome on top of a sustainability or impact outcome, whatever you want to call it – where the two are connected but very distinct. That’s almost adding a whole new dimension to the strategic debate. And my experience at Cook is that if you’re coming from the impact or sustainability side of that debate, you have to be prepared to occupy the position that says the long term is what’s important. In any short-term period, we may look horrible by whatever impact or sustainability measure we’re using. But as long as we remain committed to the long term, we shouldn’t delude ourselves that we’re failing.

Ned Wells: Yeah.

James Rutter: Because down that route, despair lies, as it were – and definite failure. So you’ve got to hold on to that long-term dream and vision, and not constantly berate yourself for short-term failures, because they will come. Particularly in the sustainability and impact space, they will come frequently, because even at its best it isn’t a linear practice. There are so many dependencies within a business that ultimately wash out in a sustainability or impact number, so you have to hold your goals and ambitions lightly – not in the sense of constantly changing them or watering them down, but in seeing that the bigger fight is always worth losing a small battle, as long as you stay in the big fight. I don’t know if that helps at all, because it’s a tricky one to answer.

Ned Wells: I think that’s good. Two things come out of it for me. One is that it requires a certain amount of bravery to keep your eye on that long-term prize. And I can also see the value of having somebody like you on side, who’s been at it for 15 years and can point to a business that has grown and succeeded by whichever metrics you choose. And, by the way, last weekend I had the most delicious pudding from Cook, which was probably the first time I’d had one. I thought it was really yummy. So, yes, a huge success in that sense. Ally, over to you.

James Rutter: Gosh, well, you’ll have to buy many more puddings.

Ally Dunnett: Thanks, Ned. I’m sure you’d be happy to buy more puddings, just in the interests of reinforcing our podcast network and our lovely guests. You’ll do that, won’t you, Ned?

Ned Wells: Of course.

Ally Dunnett: I’d like to come back to the intersection of strategy, culture and brand building. James, you started off by speaking a little to that, and I know it’s what you lead with on your personal website. It’s what you’re all about – the relationship across those three elements. Many of our listeners will be leaders in established SMEs. Can you explain how you feel strategy, culture and brand interact, or perhaps how they should interact? What does that relationship look like?

James Rutter: I definitely think it runs in that order. It starts with strategy, goes through culture, and should end up in brand.

Ultimately, what you’re looking for in strategy is clarity. In the most basic sense, do you have clarity on where you’re heading, and why? It always surprises me how many businesses, big or small, actually don’t, when you get below the surface. You should be able to get it on one piece of paper, and for it to be immediately understandable to anybody inside or outside your business: “Oh, I get it. I get what you’re doing.” So there’s that clarity piece: figuring out what the business is doing and why, where you think you can have a real advantage, and therefore what you’re focusing on.

And the classic strategy question is what you’re choosing not to do. You’ve got to be really disciplined around those choices. If a strategy doesn’t hurt, you’re probably not doing it right. So what are you saying no to, and are you really clear about that? In many respects, it’s that negative space that almost defines what you’re about. So make that strategy lovely, clear and crisp.

That should then provide the framework for all the nuts and bolts of your business, in terms of planning, budgeting and so on, and make sure it’s all coherent. That’s one of the areas where businesses, big and small, fall down. If we’re saying this is what we’re all about, and this is our long-term objective, then why are we doing X, Y and Z, which have nothing to do with it? We’re doing them because we enjoy them, or they’re fun, or they’re a legacy, or the boss just likes football – whatever it might be, you know what I mean?

Ally Dunnett: Yeah, yeah.

James Rutter: It’s really hard to say no to some of those things and let them go. But really think about whether everything you’re doing adds up to that simple strategic picture.

Once that’s clear, there’s the cultural bit. There’s the famous Peter Drucker quote, or misquote, that culture eats strategy for breakfast. Actually, your culture is how strategy gets into the world. The bit of paper is useless on its own. It’s only useful if it shapes the ideas and activities of the people who are going to make it happen. So it’s all about how we create the cultural energy that will put that plan, that business idea, into the world as effectively and efficiently as we can – getting everybody behind it, so they’re really clear about what they’re going to do, why, and how they’re going to make it happen. That’s the cultural piece.

Ally Dunnett: Mm-hmm.

James Rutter: I’m very much influenced there by the work we’ve done at Cook over many years around the idea of big relationships: ultimately, all a business boils down to is a bunch of people doing something together that they couldn’t do alone, so the relationships between those people are really the engine that drives the business forward. That’s a three-circle Venn diagram, with unity, clarity and appreciation as the three circles. You’ve got unity if you’re all on board with where you’re going – you buy into the vision and the destination. Then you’ve got clarity in terms of roles and responsibilities – it’s really clear who does what, and why. And then you’ve got appreciation of what other people bring and what you bring, in terms of recognition, reward and so on. Those three things together add up to great relationships among your team. So those are the foundations for the cultural bit.

And then the brand is how that shows up in the world. I’m a big believer that brands work from the inside out – which won’t be a surprise, given that model. So the brand is driven by your culture. What you’re showing the world should be the expression of who you are when you show up to work every day. There shouldn’t be a horrible disconnect between what happens inside the office doors and what the world sees, because down that route, probably, disaster lies. So how do you bring that internal cultural energy out into the world as a really compelling brand?

Ned Wells: Mm-hmm.

James Rutter: And, most importantly, how do you make that brand memorable? That’s the thing we’ve got to remember. We’re bombarded with messages – I can’t remember the latest number, it’s something like 2,000 a day – and you want your one little message to stand out among all that noise. So making it memorable is the most important thing. And memories get formed not by facts, but by feelings. So what are you trying to get people to feel about your brand and business? That’s where the brand bit comes to life: how do you bring that culture out into the world in a memorable way?

Ally Dunnett: Thank you.

Ned Wells: Do you mind if I jump in with a quick question on that? I know intellectually what strategy, culture and brand building mean. What I’m curious about is that those are large areas, and you were involved in them at Cook for 15 years. What did your week look like, if you see what I mean? What did you actually spend your time doing?

James Rutter: Gosh. If I’m honest, towards the end of that period – and maybe this is one of the things that prompted the change – the bit that was getting most squeezed was the brand building, because as we got bigger, the demands around culture and strategy got bigger. At certain points in the year, I was spending pretty much all my time on those.

And it’s interesting, looking back, at businesses as they grow. You do need people who are tying it all together, if that makes sense – who aren’t just in strict silos that say, “Over here we do marketing, over here we do finance, and over here we do ops.” People who genuinely work across those in a way that’s very true to the business’s purpose and culture. I think we’ve had a few people doing that at Cook, and it’s been one of the real strengths of the business. But as you get ever bigger, it becomes much harder to have people who operate like that.

Ned Wells: I think that’s what my question was about. Strategy is a very important aspect of a business, but typically you might write a strategy document with some grand statements, some objectives and some deliverables. Culture, again, is central, but it can be quite hard to put your finger on. And brand, I think, is a slightly intangible area to a lot of people. So my question is more about how you structured that side of Cook. There must have been more than just you spread across those three areas.

James Rutter: Yeah, all of those definitely were, and remain, joint endeavours with lots of people involved.

On the strategy side, one of the things I think we did very well – which I want to say we borrowed or stole from Pret – was having a very clear rhythm to how strategy works through the year. This gets back to short term and long term, you could argue. Yes, you have a three-to-five-year strategy with a plan behind it, and then you’re much clearer on the next 12 to 18 months. But each year we revisit that longer-term plan in the summer. So next week we’re going off with the Cook team to revisit the longer-term strategy. Out of that trip will come various ideas and initiatives we think we want to pursue, so everybody goes back to their teams and digs into those. Then we get back together in the autumn to put the detail on the plan for the following financial year, and maybe beyond, depending on what we’re working on. And then that repeats every year.

That cycle is really helpful in taking strategy from the lovely deck or presentation into reality. And because those moments are broadly known across the business, the invitation is there for everybody to feed in ideas and feedback. Everybody who’s going on that trip should have been out to their team to bring their team’s ideas into the strategy process. So it’s not just happening at a very esoteric top-team level. It’s built, hopefully, from much more broadly across the business. Having a rhythm to it definitely helps.

Culturally at Cook, the place where I still get most involved is events, which are a massive part of how we build culture: bringing people together, and making sure they experience Cook in a deep and rich way by spending time with people outside their day-to-day. That has probably been the strongest glue in bonding people to the organisation and to each other, beyond making sure you have great day-to-day practices in the workplace. I continue to oversee and run all the events, so again, those have a certain calendar and timing. And then brand is much more always-on: always-on comms, marketing and so on.

But for any business of any size, I think it’s really interesting to think about the rhythms that govern how you work – both across 12 months and across a single month. Are those rhythms reinforcing each other? Do they fit together? Do they help you create momentum? Or are you sometimes getting stuck or lost because the rhythm isn’t there? If you can figure out how the rhythms work, that really helps.

Ned Wells: Really interesting. Sorry, Ally, I stole your question.

Ally Dunnett: That’s quite okay, because I think we’ve got a nice segue into talking a little more about comms and marketing, if you’re happy to go on to that.

Ned Wells: Yes, indeed. Our question is about how our listeners can use comms and marketing to drive longer-term purpose and near-term revenue. I wonder if you’ve got some examples of what you’re doing today, either at Cook or with the other clients you’re working with in your fractional role.

James Rutter: Gosh, do I have any good examples of that? I’m trying to think. An area where I’ve changed my mind over the years, which I think is always interesting, is how central purpose should be in comms, or not. Ten years ago, I was definitely of the flag-waving “Why don’t we talk about our wonderful purpose all the time, at every opportunity we possibly can?” school. And what I’ve come to realise, maybe occasionally painfully, is that in whatever business you’re in, people buy an amazing product or service. They don’t buy a purpose. And you’ve always got to be so mindful of that fact.

A really helpful way to think about it, which I’m stealing with pride from a guy called Alex Smith, is that you have a company story – your purpose and values – and you have a customer story: what are you doing for the customer, in a way that’s going to deliver for them? He views those as very separate. The really interesting part, from a purpose-driven business perspective, is how much those two circles overlap. That’s where you can gain some real brand benefit, when they do. But you still mustn’t lose sight of the fact that what people are buying is an amazing product or service. You have to be cognisant of that at all times.

The company story is really important to your people, really important to you, and maybe really important to your shareholders. It might also have a role to play with customers, but don’t assume it does. At Cook, we have lots of people now who are very passionate about our purpose, which is fantastic. But I’m pretty sure they got there through eating lasagne, or chicken, ham and leek pie, or a lovely pudding.

Ned Wells: Exactly.

James Rutter: They didn’t get there through us shouting about purpose. They got there through an amazing product that made them say, “Wow, this is incredible. I want to know a bit more about the company behind this.” Maybe they read the packaging, or started to dig a bit further, or signed up to our e-newsletter. So I think that’s a really helpful idea for everybody to keep in mind: company story, customer story. Where do they overlap, and what’s going to live in that overlap? And it’s okay if not all your purpose or impact is in your customer story. Remember, the bigger prize is to create a genuinely successful business that’s a force for good. It’s not necessary to have everybody believe in your purpose.

Ned Wells: I think that’s so interesting. There’s a podcast I admire greatly called Can Marketing Save the Planet?, and there was an episode where they were talking about some research into companies. One of the examples was Octopus, which has lots of customers who aren’t especially interested in its sustainability credentials, but who like the brilliant customer service, the good pricing and all that kind of stuff. That really hit home when I heard it, and I think that’s what you’re talking about.

James Rutter: Absolutely. Octopus is a great business because it offers great service in an otherwise shitty industry – let’s be honest – at a fair price. I was reading something literally this morning about Octopus, saying they just found a gap in the market that shouldn’t have been there. Modern market economics would tell you there shouldn’t be a sector where everybody is equally crap at customer service. But there was, and it was called the UK power sector. And Octopus just said, “You know what, we don’t have to be as crap as everybody else. And as long as we charge a fair price, everybody’s going to love us.” And there you go – £10 billion later, or whatever it’s valued at these days.

Ned Wells: Ally, over to you.

Ally Dunnett: Thank you. I’m still reflecting on a few things there. I think it’s so interesting, that point about not having to have purpose front and centre of your external communications – just letting it seep through, letting it hit or not hit. And chances are it will hit, even if your customers or clients came to you for another reason initially. I also keep coming back to your various Venn diagrams, because you’re all about Venn diagrams, James. I like thinking in that way.

James Rutter: I managed to post a Venn diagram every week for a year, which I felt quite pleased about at the end. And then I thought, “You know what, I don’t think anybody’s really waiting for my next Venn diagram.” So I quietly stopped.

Ally Dunnett: I love a Venn diagram. I keep an eye out now, since you spoke to us about them when we first chatted. But, to move us on a little, we always like to ask whether there are any interesting developments coming up for you. That could be at Cook, or in the way you want to shape your own independent work in the next 12 months or so.

James Rutter: I’m just going to say this, because then it might force me to do it, having said it in public. One of the things I did when I started my little solopreneur business was think, “Oh, great, I’ll do a monthly newsletter. That’s going to be really easy.” And I quickly found out that doing a monthly newsletter when you’ve got loads of other stuff on is not very easy at all. After about three months it died a quiet death. It’s not like I had an audience of thousands.

Ally Dunnett: Ha ha.

James Rutter: But I’m committed. I want to get a newsletter up and running, and I’ve got an idea that’s a little bit fleshed out. I’m planning a weekly newsletter called The Secret Strategist. It’s a new slant on strategy for anybody who’s supposed to know what it means but often doesn’t – which is most of us, because it’s one of those words that everybody bandies around, and not many people actually know what it means. So I’m planning to launch The Secret Strategist over the summer.

Ally Dunnett: Great. Well, we’ll be looking for it, so that will hold you to it, as you say. That sounds great. I love it. Ned?

Ned Wells: James, we’re reaching the end of our time, which is a shame, but I’ve got a couple of ending questions. The first is about the food and retail sectors. Where do you hope they’ll be in 10 years’ time?

James Rutter: Where do I hope they’ll be, or where do I think they’ll be? Those are two very different questions. And I’d say food retail specifically, rather than food and retail.

It just makes me cry sometimes how bad our approach to food retail is in this country. There are a couple of instances recently that really hit home for me. In London Bridge station – this must be going back maybe five years, maybe longer – one of the big companies that owns those sites in transport hubs wanted to test a new format of convenience store within a station. They created this lovely space at London Bridge, with a great variety of things, including two Cook freezers, and a good selection of interesting food. It had some pretty high-end wine, and some books. It felt like a really lovely, high-end place. But it’s now reverted to a classic convenience store, with rows upon rows of chocolate, crappy sandwiches and protein drinks, and not a lot else. That just made me sad.

And equally, near me here in Kent, in a town called Headcorn, there was a lovely deli. I can’t remember what it was called, but it did some lovely, locally made things, and again it had some lovely Cook freezers in there. It must have been there for five or so years. Suddenly, out of the blue, it shut just before Christmas. No idea what happened. And now it’s turned into a fried chicken takeaway, with a vape shop on one side and a UPF-toting newsagent on the other.

Ned Wells: Oh, no.

James Rutter: It just makes me despair a bit, because ultimately food culture drives so much else. Think about health outcomes, which impact economic outcomes, which impact society. And we’re failing to see how these things connect. Without some really bold and intentional action, we’re just going to keep sliding further into the abyss on this kind of stuff.

Sorry, that’s a very depressing thing to say, isn’t it? But that’s why I despair a bit of food retail specifically in this country. Without more proactive action, particularly from government – and we’ve started to make a few baby steps in that direction – linking things like food, health and education more closely together, we’re probably not going to end up in a very good place in 10 years. What we’ll end up with is a very high-end, expensive, quote-unquote “good” end of the market, and a very big swathe that’s pretty depressing.

Ally Dunnett: Yes, that’s easy to picture, isn’t it? That increased polarisation.

James Rutter: Yeah. Sorry, I shouldn’t be so depressing, should I? Because there is some good stuff at the same time.

Ned Wells: It’s fascinating. I wanted to put a spotlight on Cook’s longer-term plan to grow at 10 or 15%, I think you said. My reflection was: is growth always a good thing? Do we need growth? But in the light of what you’ve said, where there’s a clear opportunity for organisations to grow into an area that’s so shit in food retail, I can see that sort of growth being really positive.

James Rutter: Yeah, and the growth question is always a really interesting one for anybody who takes sustainability and the planet’s boundaries seriously. It’s a very serious question. And yet the challenge is that, as businesses, we operate in a market that largely ignores all those challenges. We mustn’t kid ourselves that isn’t the case. There are, whatever, 3,000 B Corps in the UK, and I want to say three million or six million registered businesses, or something – I don’t know. It’s literally a drop in the ocean.

So the imperative for us, as purpose-driven, impact-seeking businesses, is genuinely to be as successful as we possibly can. Because through our success, we’ll hopefully inspire other people, show people that a different way is possible, and, to a degree, start to shame other businesses into doing some similar things. So on the one hand you can have the anguish about growing in a planetary environment where we’re already exceeding the boundaries. But the other imperative is that if you’ve got the seed of a great thing, you need to keep going and keep figuring out how to make it as successful as you possibly can. That’s your obligation. Having started down that road, your obligation isn’t to give up and say, “Work’s done,” because the challenge is immense.

Ned Wells: And it’s not a trivial question, nor is there a single, easy answer.

James Rutter: God, no. Absolutely. And business is tough as well. I’ll leave you with one factoid, though I can’t quite remember the details. Some research from about five years ago looked at the performance of B Corps – I think it was based in the US. Over the preceding decade, mostly retail-facing or FMCG-type B Corps outperformed the general market by a significant amount – I want to say 10%. I’ve got the slides somewhere. And I think that research has been updated more recently for the UK, showing a very similar result.

My leap of faith in interpreting that data point is that business is blooming hard to succeed at the best of times. Then you add on all the constraints that come with being a B Corp – or whatever wrapper you choose, as long as it has some genuine constraints. You’ve got to be so good at operating a business that you actually perform a bit better than average. Embracing those constraints – adding a load of pain to what’s already a pretty painful process of trying to succeed in business – almost means embracing a more rigorous way of operating. So your chances of performing, surviving and succeeding are just that little bit better than the average bear’s, because you’ve got that extra bit of commitment and that extra bit of rigour contributing to your performance.

Ned Wells: So fascinating. Ally, over to you.

Ally Dunnett: Very good. My usual concluding question – you’ve given us so much good advice already for businesses trying to balance sustainability with hitting their financial targets. But would you pick out one piece of advice for other businesses trying to strike that balance?

James Rutter: I would go for clarity – slightly talking my own book. You have got to get really clear, both on the strategy for the business, and on your strategy and ambitions on the sustainability or impact side of things, and how those two connect and link together, or not. Getting really clear on that will help you avoid a lot of anguish and pain down the line. And just accept that it is always hard, and there are always trade-offs, and that doesn’t make you a bad person or a bad businessperson. You have to make some trade-offs in order to survive and prosper. So accept that, but never lose sight of the bigger prize.

Ally Dunnett: Great, thank you.

Ned Wells: I guess the burning question for me is: strategy – what is it? Do you have four or five things at your fingertips that you need to think about? Because it’s huge and important, but, as you say, often not that easy to visualise.

James Rutter: So many definitions, and they’re all equally vague and rubbish. But I do think there’s some truth in strategy as choice. Being able to put on a piece of paper the intentional choices you’re making to move you further towards a desired outcome you think is valuable – if you can do that, you’re part of the way there. And then, how are you going to make sure you follow each of those choices right through your organisation? I think that’s a decent definition.

Ned Wells: Nice one. We’ll wrap it up there. That was brilliant. Thank you, James. Finally, how can people find out more about you?

James Rutter: Thank you both. I try to post a thought or two on LinkedIn every week, so do look me up there – search for James Rutter and I guess you’ll find me. And my personal website is james-rutter.com.

Ned Wells: Awesome. What fun. That was brilliant, James. Thank you.

Ally Dunnett: Yeah, thank you.

James Rutter: Pleasure.

  • James Rutter

    Cook

    James Rutter is Chief Strategy Officer at Cook, the frozen food business. Since he joined, Cook has grown from £25-30 million to around £150 million in sales.

    Alongside this, he currently spends two days a week working with purpose-driven businesses on how strategy, culture and brand fit together.

    Follow me on LinkedIn